Eagle Rare 17 Year Kentucky Straight Bourbon

Sell your Eagle Rare 17 Year

Antique Collection · 101 proof · 750ml

Typical offer

$550

For a sealed, full bottle · Updated Nov 4, 2026

Paid in 5–7 daysZelle, Venmo or ACH
Free shippingPacking kit sent to you
Rated 4.9100+ verified reviews

Seen higher prices at auction?

Auction houses can only give estimates, never a guaranteed offer.

High auction fees

Seller commission, lot and reserve fees, and often photo charges. A buyer's premium holds bids down.

Paid weeks later

Weeks after the auction closes, once the buyer pays, and only if it sells.

You're 100% liable for shipping

You buy materials, pay for shipping and hope it arrives.

With We Buy Bottles

A firm cash offer, paid in 5–7 days, free insured shipping.

Three steps to get paid

Get your offer
Send a few photos and we get you an offer within 48 hours.
Ship it free
We send a shipping kit to your doorstep. Drop it off at a UPS location.
Get paid
We inspect it and pay you in 5–7 days.

What is Eagle Rare 17 Year worth?

Eagle Rare 17 Year keeps its value as the oldest regular bottle in the Buffalo Trace Antique Collection, released once a year in the fall. It's a bourbon aged seventeen years and bottled at 101 proof, made at Buffalo Trace in Frankfort, Kentucky. The everyday Eagle Rare is a ten year bourbon found on most shelves; the 17 is a very different bottle, and far harder to find.

What your bottle is worth depends on condition. A sealed bottle with the capsule and any tax strip intact, a full fill, a clean label and a sound cork brings the most. The original tissue wrap is a plus. The release year printed on the label matters, so a clear photo of the back label helps us give you an exact offer.

Our typical offer for a sealed, full Eagle Rare 17 Year is $550 cash. Send us a few photos and you'll have a firm offer within 48 hours, with a packing kit shipped to your door.